Push syndication

[fanf]

Some of my friends think Livejournal should be news though I'm not really convinced. Although using NNTP as the transport protocol has significant efficiency advantages, it doesn't help with the interesting problems of distributing LJ's network effects.

I tend to think that a more modern solution to the efficiency problem would be to create a way for (RSS or Atom etc.) syndication feed updates to be pushed rather than pulled (and polled). Fortunately this is a sufficiently obvious approach that other people are working on it so I can just sit back and let the lazy web do its thing. But what protocol should be used for the notifications?

My answer comes via the Radio Free RFC episodes about XMPP. The Extensible Messaging and Presence Protocol, aka Jabber, is the IETF's open standard for instant messaging. It has an extension known as PubSub which supports generic publication of update notifcations and subscription to a notification feed, and there's a profile of PubSub for handling updates to an Atom feed: http://www.xmpp.org/drafts/draft-saintandre-atompub-notify-02.html

All that remains to be worked out is how to handle the interesting access control features of "friends" lists in a distributed and easy-to-use manner...

Comments

[pjc50.livejournal.com]

The "interesting access control features" are the core of livejournal's advantage, not an add-on. Note also that it's very hard to distribute, as e.g. the information about who can see a post is private to the poster.

Livejournal solves the single-sign-on problem within its domain. It also provides centralised anti-abuse services, another thing which is hard to replicate.